This photograph is a tin type, labeled only “Aunt Mae”.
Given that I think the photograph might have been labeled by Amanda H Davis (1861-1902), daughter of Emily Jane Melton (1835-1910) and William T Davis (1831-1863), stepdaughter of William T Olive (b 1838), of Fayette County, Alabama, that makes sisters and sisters-in-law of her parents good candidates.
Sisters of Emily Jane Melton:
- Mary H Melton m. William Threet Poe
- Louise H Melton m. Joseph B Barnett
- Helen E Melton
- Amelia Franklin Melton m. Frank M Black
- Martha Ellen Melton m. James Hillard Olive
Brothers of Emily Jane Melton, with their wives:
- Jefferson Melton
- Meedy White Melton m. Mary F Cannon
- William Melton
- Melton Melton
- Willis B Melton m. Flora Hastletine South
Sisters of William T Davis:
- Sarah E Davis m. M C Davis
- Martha Davis m. Joel Gibson
- Maranda Saphira Davis m. Thomas H Angle
- Matilda F Davis m. Green R Gibson
- Mary E Davis
Brothers of William T Davis, with their wives:
- John Minor Davis
- James M Davis
- Willis Davis
Sisters of William T Olive:
- Sarah J Olive m. William J Campbell
- Mary E Olive m. Michael Richard Tierce
- Samantha Ann Olive m. Thomas Jefferson Davis
- Permelia F Olive m. Rufus H Davis
- Matilda Olive m. William E Kuykendall
Brothers of William T Olive, with their wives:
- Lewis J Olive
- James Hillard Olive m. Martha Ellen Melton
- Wyatt J Olive
- Robert C Olive
- Julus Olive
- John C Olive m. Neoma E Stocks
- Richard Monroe Olive m. Rosa Best
None of these people make an obvious “Aunt Mae”, but Mae could be a nickname, and many of the sisters-in-law are not yet identified.